Should I have predictive genetic testing for motor neurone disease?

Information about Predictive Genetic Testing for MND

This decision tool is for you if:

  • You have a family history of MND and a faulty MND gene has been identified in a family member
  • You are planning a family with someone who has a family history of MND and a faulty gene has been identified in one of their family members
  • You are considering being tested for MND genes

This decision tool is designed to help you and your family discuss your choices with your MND doctor or genetic counselor. The tool summarizes research and best practice information to help people make decisions about predictive genetic testing for MND. Genetic testing allows people to be aware if they are carrying a fault (or mutation) in an MND gene, so that they can make decisions and plans for their life.

You may not feel ready to read all the information contained in this tool. If so, read the information you wish to know, at the best time for you. If you would like more detailed information, links to other resources are provided in the relevant sections, and in the resources at the end of this tool.

MND is a general term applying to progressive, degenerative disorders affecting the motor neurones. It is also known as Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) in Europe and the UK, but in Australia, the term MND is more often used. Motor neurones carry signals from the brain to the muscles. In people with motor neurone disease, the motor neurones deteriorate and can no longer carry these signals. This is a gradual process, which causes muscles to waste away. Some people carry genetic faults that predispose them to this motor neurone deterioration, and these people are at increased risk of developing MND over their lifetime.

Families with a gene fault or a strong family history of MND are known to have familial MND (also known as "FALS"). About 10% of all people with MND will have familial MND, meaning the risk can be inherited. The remaining 90% of people with MND have ‘sporadic MND’, meaning that only one person in the family has the disease. Age of onset of familial MND varies from family to family and depends on the gene fault involved. Still, not everyone with a faulty gene will go on to develop MND, and it is important to know that we currently are unable to predict if, when and how MND may affect someone with a faulty MND gene.

A condition called frontotemporal dementia (FTD) can also be caused by some gene faults that can also cause MND. FTD is a form of dementia and associated with changes in behaviour, language and personality. In these families, some family members may have had MND, FTD or a combination of both conditions. MND Australia has more information about MND and FTD

A faulty gene or ‘genetic mutation’ is an error in a person’s genetic code which prevents a gene from working normally. We have around 20,000 genes and no one has a complete working set- we are likely to each have faults in a number of genes. Most people have two fully functioning copies of each gene- one set inherited from their mother, and the other set inherited from their father.

Usually, a person only needs one faulty copy of any of the genes associated with MND to lead to an increased chance of the disease developing. People with a parent who carries an MND gene have a 50% chance of inheriting the same gene fault. This is known as autosomal dominant inheritance; in other words, when one parent carries the autosomal dominant faulty gene copy.

Diagram adapted from http://www.genetics.edu.au/publications-and- resources/facts-sheets/fact-sheet-8-autosomal-dominant-inheritance

For more information about genetic mutations that cause MND, please visit the U.S. National Library of Medicine

Genetic testing in family members can allow each person to know whether they have inherited the same faulty MND gene, and if they are at increased risk of developing disease. Not everyone with a faulty gene will go on to develop MND. However, the chance of developing MND is much higher for those carrying MND genes. This chance depends on the faulty gene involved, and sometimes even the family specific mutation. At this time, we currently are unable to predict if, when and how MND may affect someone with a faulty MND gene.

  • Not all the gene faults that cause MND are known. To date, several genes that are associated with MND risk have been identified. The most commonly tested MND genes are: SOD1 and C9orf72. The C9orf72 gene is thought to cause around 40% of familial MND in Australia. Having this mutation may result in people developing MND, frontotemporal dementia (FTD) or a combination of both MND and FTD. The SOD1 gene is responsible for a further 20% of cases of familial MND.
  • Around 40% of people with familial MND, identified by a strong family history of the disease, do not carry an identified gene fault.
  • Occasionally, genetic testing may find that someone thought to have "sporadic MND" has "familial MND" because they carry an identified gene mutation.
  • If you have a known genetic fault for MND in your family and find out through testing that you don’t have it, your risk of disease is the same as anyone else the general population of developing sporadic MND.

Testing is usually done with a simple blood test. Testing for MND genes is optional, and can only be done with your signed consent. There are two types of genetic testing that can be performed.

  1. Diagnostic genetic testing: This is also known as ‘mutation search genetic testing’. This is a test performed when no gene fault has previously been identified in the family. It is usually performed on a person with MND and may test a single MND gene, or multiple MND genes. Before testing, genetic counselling is available to help you decide if proceeding with testing is right for you.

You could also elect to provide a blood sample and store it until you or your family have decided to proceed with testing. This can be particularly important if you or other family members felt the timing was not right to undergo genetic testing.

  1. Predictive genetic testing: This test is available to relatives once an MND gene fault has been identified in the family. The test is known as a 'predictive' test as it will inform you whether you do (or don't) carry the family faulty gene, and therefore whether you do (or don't) have an increased risk of MND over your lifetime. Before testing, genetic counselling is required to help you decide if proceeding with testing is right for you. This is a requirement even if you are sure that you wish to have the testing. A referral from a GP is enough to book an appointment at a testing clinic.

It is also possible that you may be offered ‘confirmatory genetic testing’. This is a test that is done in a family member to confirm whether they carry the gene fault in the family. The test is considered ‘confirmatory’ rather than ‘predictive’ if someone already has symptoms of MND or FTD and therefore are likely to carry the same gene change.

The decision to have genetic testing is completely voluntary. The results are completely confidential, and can’t be shared without your express consent. Even if you choose to share your results with researchers, they will remain anonymous.

Reproductive genetic testing is also possible and is further detailed in "How does genetic testing help me decide about family planning".

Many families find that each member has a different attitude towards having genetic testing, and knowing the results of their test. While some family members may be supportive of your decision to have or to decline testing, others may not. It is your choice who you discuss your decision with.

Your GP can refer you to health professionals who specialise in genetic testing services. Genetic counsellors will be able to provide you with expert information about genetic testing for MND that is specific to your family situation. They also offer support through your decision-making, and as you learn about your results, and what they mean for you. There are many genetic counselling clinics across Australia. The Human Genetics Society of Australia provides a list of public and private options for genetic counselling to help you find a local genetics counselling service.

Other professionals who can provide information include MND doctors and health professionals, advisors from your local MND associations, and your GP. For more information about familial MND, you can also contact the MND team who has treated the person with MND in your family.

MND Australia also provides information and advice for MND patients, carers and family. A fact sheet on genetic testing for familial MND can be found at MND Australia.

(Adapted from https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/primer/consult/expectations)

During a genetic counselling appointment, the genetic counsellor or other health professional provides information, offers support, and addresses a patient’s specific questions and concerns about a family history of disease, a specific genetic condition and/or genetic testing.

During a consultation, a genetics professional will:

  • Review your personal health history and family history of MND and/or FTD.
  • Interpret and communicate complex medical information in a meaningful and non-judgmental way. This may include information about a diagnosis, how the condition is inherited, the chance of passing the condition to future generations, and the options for testing and treatment.
  • Help each person make informed, independent decisions about their health care and reproductive options.
  • Respect each person’s individual beliefs, traditions, and feelings.

A genetics professional will NOT:

  • Tell a person which decision to make.
  • Advise a couple not to have children.
  • Recommend that a woman continue or end a pregnancy.
  • Tell someone whether to undergo testing for a genetic disorder.

Family planning for people with an inherited condition has always been a complex issue. To assist their decision-making, some familial MND family members decide to have genetic testing in conjunction with In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF). Some IVF clinics can test embryos before they are implanted to determine whether they carry an MND gene.

Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) involves screening IVF-generated embryos for genetic conditions prior to embryo transfer. Parents can then choose how they proceed with implantation.

IVF clinics can provide information on pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, and on where this specialist screening is available. They can also provide information on the associated costs and the Medicare rebates available.

As with other inherited conditions, genetic testing can also be conducted after a pregnancy has occurred.

Once a gene mutation has been identified in a family, couples who are planning a family can consider options that may help to prevent a gene mutation being passed on:

  1. Do nothing. If a couple conceives naturally and chooses not to undergo testing of the pregnancy, there would be up to a 1 in 2 chance that each pregnancy will have inherited the faulty MND gene.
  2. Do nothing, conceive naturally and undergo prenatal diagnosis. From approximately 10.5 weeks, couples can elect to have genetic testing on the pregnancy using chorionic villus sampling (CVS). CVS involves using a needle to take a sample of the placental cells. These cells contain DNA from the pregnancy and can be used to test if the faulty gene is present. Amniocentesis is another needle test that is available from approximately 16 weeks. CVS has a 1% (or 1 in 100) risk of miscarriage, and amniocentesis has a 0.5% (1 in 200) risk. Based on the information from the needle testing or ultrasounds, couples can then elect to stop the pregnancy if the faulty gene is confirmed.
  3. Undergo IVF with a plan to do pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). PGD is a process in which embryos are tested prior to implantation into the womb and only those embryos that are not affected are implanted. The benefits of PGD are that couples can prevent passing on the condition to children, and not be faced with the option of termination of pregnancy. Unfortunately, as with all IVF procedures, there is no guarantee of a healthy pregnancy and PGD can be costly.
  4. Other options include use of donor egg, sperm or embryo, adoption and choosing not to have children.
  5. There are also options available if a person decides they do not want to undergo predictive testing for themselves. This is known as exclusion testing and can be performed with PGD, and sometimes, with prenatal diagnosis.

Decisions about family planning can be complex. Your genetic counsellor could further discuss these aspects with you, or you could consider referral to an IVF clinic.

The testing must be voluntary, and the person undertaking must be able to give informed consent and be over 18 years of age. If you choose to undergo genetic testing, the results of your test will not be released to others without your formal consent.

Testing costs vary considerably, depending on the type of testing being conducted, and the type of genetics service you access. Many public genetic testing services may provide subsidised or free testing for MND-related genes, especially if you are from a familial MND family. Other services may be expensive, so it is wise to ask about costs beforehand.

Genetics research is attempting to identify new genes that can cause MND. Once we understand how these genes work, new methods of treatment for people living with MND are hoped to be developed.

What are my Options?

Choose predictive genetic testing
"I am hopeful of a negative result"The chance of testing negative for familial MND is at least 50%.
"Others in my family has been tested, and I want to know my result"Some people want to know everything they can about MND in their family.
"I want to know if I could pass a gene onto my future children"Information from genetic testing can assist choices for family planning.
"I want to feel more certain"For some people, not knowing their result or what the future might hold is more distressing than knowing it.
“I want to be prepared if I do have the gene”Some people prefer to know their risk of familial MND when they plan their life ahead. Anticipating future needs helps some people to feel psychologically prepared for their future, or be proactive about their work, lifestyle and healthcare.
"I want my children to know their risk of MND"Some parents may want testing so their children can be aware of whether they are at risk of familial MND.
"Knowing that I don’t have the gene will give me reassurance for my financial future"Employment, banking, and insurance implications of testing positive need to be considered.
"I want to contribute to research"You can choose to contribute to research even without knowing your genetic testing result.
Delay or decline predictive genetic testing
"You can't cure it, so what is the point of knowing if I have it or not."Genetic testing would be more helpful if there was a cure or treatments available for people with an MND gene fault.
"MND does not control my life"Other aspects of life may be more important to you than knowing your risk of MND
"I don’t want to think about MND"Dwelling on a possible future with MND can be distressing
"I don’t have children"

Some people feel that there is no reason to test for an inherited condition if there is no future generation.

"I would be devastated if I had the gene"

For some, knowing they had the gene fault could have a negative effect on their mood and sense of wellbeing.

"I would feel guilty if I didn’t have the gene"

Some people experience 'survivor guilt' if they do not have the gene fault, but other family members do.

"I would be upset if I thought had passed the gene onto my children"For some, knowing they had passed on the gene to their children could cause them distress.
"I will cross that bridge when I come to it" "Even if I have the gene fault, I can't predict how, if and when it will cause MND in me."For some people, looking too far into the future is futile, as you can never be sure what will happen.

"I am not ready to have genetic testing now"

Genetic testing is available for you whenever you are ready.

"I am hopeful a cure will be found in the future"

Research continues to strive for a cure or effective treatments to stop the impact of MND.

"I worry about how genetic testing results will affect my relationships"
"My family would be angry if I was tested"

Some people feel that knowing their result would upset family members and friends. Not all family members will share the same view on genetic testing. It is a very personal decision.
"I am hopeful of a negative result"The chance of testing negative for familial MND is at least 50%.
"Others in my family has been tested, and I want to know my result"Some people want to know everything they can about MND in their family.
"I want to know if I could pass a gene onto my future children"Information from genetic testing can assist choices for family planning.
"I want to feel more certain"For some people, not knowing their result or what the future might hold is more distressing than knowing it.
“I want to be prepared if I do have the gene”Some people prefer to know their risk of familial MND when they plan their life ahead. Anticipating future needs helps some people to feel psychologically prepared for their future, or be proactive about their work, lifestyle and healthcare.
"I want my children to know their risk of MND"Some parents may want testing so their children can be aware of whether they are at risk of familial MND.
"Knowing that I don’t have the gene will give me reassurance for my financial future"Employment, banking, and insurance implications of testing positive need to be considered.
"I want to contribute to research"You can choose to contribute to research even without knowing your genetic testing result.
"You can't cure it, so what is the point of knowing if I have it or not."Genetic testing would be more helpful if there was a cure or treatments available for people with an MND gene fault.
"MND does not control my life"Other aspects of life may be more important to you than knowing your risk of MND
"I don’t want to think about MND"Dwelling on a possible future with MND can be distressing
"I don’t have children"

Some people feel that there is no reason to test for an inherited condition if there is no future generation.

"I would be devastated if I had the gene"

For some, knowing they had the gene fault could have a negative effect on their mood and sense of wellbeing.

"I would feel guilty if I didn’t have the gene"

Some people experience 'survivor guilt' if they do not have the gene fault, but other family members do.

"I would be upset if I thought had passed the gene onto my children"For some, knowing they had passed on the gene to their children could cause them distress.
"I will cross that bridge when I come to it" "Even if I have the gene fault, I can't predict how, if and when it will cause MND in me."For some people, looking too far into the future is futile, as you can never be sure what will happen.

"I am not ready to have genetic testing now"

Genetic testing is available for you whenever you are ready.

"I am hopeful a cure will be found in the future"

Research continues to strive for a cure or effective treatments to stop the impact of MND.

"I worry about how genetic testing results will affect my relationships"
"My family would be angry if I was tested"

Some people feel that knowing their result would upset family members and friends. Not all family members will share the same view on genetic testing. It is a very personal decision.

What matters most to you?

Reasons to have genetic testing:

1. I want more certainty about my risk of having MND


2. I want to plan my family knowing my risks


3. I want to be prepared for my future


4. I want to be prepared for the future of my family members


Reasons to decline genetic testing:

1. Knowing I have an MND gene would be too distressing for me


2. Having genetic testing would upset my family


3. Knowing my result won’t change how I live my life


4. There is no cure yet


Indicate below how important genetic testing is to you overall:

1. How important genetic testing is to you overall?


2. Is being tested an important choice for you right now?


Result:

What are your reasons for having or not having or delaying Genetic Testing?

Check the facts

1) Genetic testing does not yet test for all the possible genes responsible for MND


2) In predictive genetic testing, a negative result guarantees that you will never get MND


3) Genetic testing for MND has associated financial cost and legal obligations


4) Undertaking or declining genetic testing may have personal and social consequences


How certain do you feel about making your decision?

1) Do you know the benefits and consequences of each option?


2) Are you clear about which benefits and consequences matter most to you?


3) Do you have enough support and advice to make a choice?


4) Do you feel sure about the best choice for you?


What do you want to do?


Result:

For More Information

References

From Australia:
Centre for Genetics Education
MND Australia

From the USA:
US National Library of Medicine, https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/primer/consult/expectations
Crook, A, Williams, K, Adams, L, Blair, I & Rowe, DB (2017): Predictive genetic testing for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and frontotemporal dementia: genetic counseling considerations, Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis, and Frontotemporal Degeneration, DOI: 10.1080/21678421.2017.1332079

Acknowledgements

A Hogden, A Crook

Students: C Poole, W Seach (Macquarie University)

Format adapted from the Ottawa Personal Decision Guide © 2000, A O’Connor, D Stacey, University of Ottawa, Canada.

Print

Please Provide Your Feedback

How would you describe your overall satisfaction?